Wenn man sich so die Kritiken, Konzertberichte und Kommentare zu Pink Floyd bzw. David Gilmours Musik so durchliest fäll mir auf, dass immer wieder bestimmte Wörter, Sätze fallen: „Genial, Wahnsinn, keine Wörter können das beschreiben, Tränen in den Augen, Magie, Seele, Sprachlos, Herz, Soviel Gefühl in der Musik…“
Ich bin auch immer wieder überrascht wenn ich lese, dass andere beim genießen dieser Musik praktisch die gleichen Gefühlen haben, das gleiche denken. Zur Illustration folgende Beispiele (Youtube Kommentare):
Zu David Gilmour:
- every single song by this man is a masterpiece…………. 14rush14
- I honestly don’t think I could live without this music. flydfan
- gilmour is like wine…..you know the rest solarpanels3
- whn my 3-year-old daughter asks me to „put on Floyd, daddy“, i think the future generations still have hope. GonEfe32
- no words can describe it Jheadley13
- @MrPeggyo your right roger waters is a musical genius but he would have not been as significant if it wasnt for davids contributions. david is the voice and sound behind pink floyd , best guitar player ever and great vocals . mike623100
- o my god!!!! that is such amazing music! i was in a trance in the solo. so spacey!! billymiskimmin
- David Gilmour is a Legend TheRacist123
- I’d like to hear Gilmour make a solo album with this kind of sound. Hogweed11
- Im still having shivers when im listening this song…this music is so much more than just a music. It’s a spiritual experience. neyoam
- when goofing off turns into something sublime. classic. kthulu
- This is musical Magic. I could listen to them all day. doesithurt09
- Just a jam and still better than anything else today 🙂 jvandle
- nobody can touch david gilmour…. s1lvrinferno
- This is glorious ! dullsvillain
- so that’s the quality of just pure jamming, which is even better than actually produced ALBUMS for some rock stars of these days..RESPECT to Dave and Rick from EGYPT kamalovetch
- if aliens exist, .. they would abduct Gilmour… just to listen… dannyhughs
- When Gilmour smiles, you know everything is fine … Kafrifelle
- one note is all they needed to know whats coming wispa1a
- Simplemente perfecto. Simply perfect. Musical poetry in its maximal expression. Poesia musical en su maxima expresion. mememeome
- @SandySandra27 Thanks, Rick is Echoes,it’s his soul in the song. This to me explains Pink Floyd at it’s core. GilmourTrueHD
- gilmour you are the lord of music, your guitar work moves my soul. your skills make me speechless. thank you for all the great work boys.dirtypossem
- I feel sorry for anyone who has never heard this song, simply amazing.emosikoloto
- heaven is a place where this song doesn’t end. xBullFrogHD
- My Boyfriend said to me that Petrucci Play’s Comfortably solo better than David Gilmour .he’s not my boyfriend anymore Mollyfender1996
- If heaven does exist, this must be the song at its entrance port! It is amazing how a human being can create such a beatiful object, such a song. babaloushka
- these aren’t just pretty little notes he’s playing. his music tells a story. there’s a beginning, a middle and an end. it takes you to another place. fishsherman
- In a class by himself…. gbrycki
- david gilmour is the prove that fast playing is unnecessary. Petiber
- Who will fill the void left by floyd? tommysoldier
- why don’t modern day bands play like this, all you hear now is noice , no more beautiful guitar solos… its true what they say rock and roll is dead vegatron77
- Too bad Gilmour and Presley didn’t do the song together. whoisit2112
- David Gilmour is a huge inspiration for my playing.“Comfortaby numb“ and „Shine on..“ are my personal favorites solos. His flawless technique and his soulful licks are unique. Everyone these days can play fast guitar licks but only a few can touch your soul.The right note at the right time.Pure genius. Some days ago I wrote a song named „Likvidator(the warning)“ where the solo is mainly influenced by the way he plays.In some way is my humble tribute to the master(you can listen it on my channel) edmusicchile
- How to spend 22 poetic minutes of anyone’s life. Light90Sephiroth
- My sister: Turn that music down! I’m can hear it from my room and I’m trying to concentrate. Me: But it’s Pink Floyd! By my own standard, I’m required to make it exponentially louder than any other music that passes through my speaker. My sister: *sigh* When will you turn it down? Me: About 22 minutes. EvilWalruses(Kommentar zu Echoes Gdanskl)
- God I would do anything to be in a Pink Floyd sound check, even if it’s just David. PolysaturatedFat
- Fucking Geniuses… So glad it’s all recorded and they are still around. Listen kids and you will see that long ago there were incredibly talented musicians… Practice hard and be the future genius musicians. CatboxDesign
- david gilmour in my humble opinion may not be the best or fastest guitar player in the world, but he is the best guitar player in MY world, you can feel his soul come through those strings, im 53 years old now, i just saw the wall show in ft lauderdale, it was fantastic even without david, but you definitly can tell he wasnt there, i pray that someday david and roger get together and just do one more album, along with nick,,and god rest richard wrights soul. i love pink floyd forever..peace out jetaholic
- 1. go to google translator. 2. translate „will pink floyd ever die“ from English to Vietnamese. 3. Copy Vietnamese text and translate it back to English. 4. Your question has been answered. beebo777
- When I’m sad (like anytime) I’m listening Us And Them. When I want to listen an timeless song , I listen time. When money didn’t have an worth for me , I listen Money. When I’m high, I listen Confortably Numb and Another Brick In The Wall. When I’m in an depression, I listen Hey You And Shine On Your Crazy Diamond. When I’m falled in love, I listen Wish You Were Here. Pink Floyd is my life, David is my God. My Respect to Pink Floyd ! Cheers from Romania ^^. HossuFlaviu
- has a guitar ever sounded better?? zac030101
- If you ever watch interviews with him, it seems that like his playing, he considers what he is going to say, then says it with as few words as possible, but with maximum impact. ep9229
- he is very talented.almost like the rainman of music.i like the way he holds his hands and rubs them as he talks and kind looks at the camera from the top of his eyes…i think he has a tick..and i think thats just b/c he is so musically inclined that he would rather play than talk. he probably has music playing in his head constantly. would love to meet him. chrisyo77
- The best thing about Dave is he does not jump around when he weeps the guitar deansusky
- It’s easy to associate rock stardom with being abrasive, crude and downright unpleasant. But David Gilmour is such a warm and comforting presence as well as an amazing musician. Kids, if you’re gonna be a rock star, be more like this guy. Your colleagues and fans will thank you for it. XnovemberrisingX
- Dave Mustain: David Gilmour can do more with a note than most guitarist can do with the entire frets virusAlex20
- you’ve heard the old cliche about a bottle of wine getting better with age, it’s appropriate here, David is just amazing Tifflet
- Masterpiece of creativity. ledzeppsam
- Truly spectacular. GilmourishGuitarist
- If Gilmour sang the cooking instructions off a tin of rice pudding it would sound special. The guy’s a genius, a true alchemist of sound. randomdave30
- no band will EVER, sound like pink floyd yngwierulez
- It really breaks my heart that I’ve never seen my favorite band play. jukebox80sman
- I was welling up like I was going to cry — and sure enough, one lone tear just rolled half way down my face. What David stirs up in the souls of people and brings to the surface … it’s surreal. KarmicOmen
- David is probably one of the few musicians who can express emotions trough his guitar. I can’t help thinking that legends like Led Zeppelin, Jimmy Hendrix, Pink Floyd (to name a few) will be forgotten and commercial artists like Lady GaGa, Justin Bieber and Rihanna will take over today’s music which makes me feel very sad. I’m one of the very few sixteen year-olds who listens and appreciates this music. Pink floyd is music and will live everafter GreekBoy2007
- David Gilmore is a Legend! Incredible Talent! christrealized
- If heaven exists, I hope there is music like this there…seriously. bopplayer
- I love this song!!! This justs makes me feel good about life!!! Amazing what his music can do!!!! Rock on David Gilmour!!!! CJason09
- To be honest, David Gilmour doesnt need to talk, he does that with his guitar. Area5107
- this is the song i want to play at my wedding, the union of two souls forever Lebowski310
- Greatest guitarist ever to come out of rock history IMHO! David plays with such emotion and heart that no one else can do with a guitar. I apologize to Clapton and Beck and Hendrix fans but David Gilmour is rock’s greatest guitarist. Been a fan since I was a small child and was the reason why I play guitar. His playing can prove that you can play more feeling with less notes. Those who bash Gilmour are just either into showoffs or just musical snobs who don’t like real music and/or art! floydgenesisnut
- David Gilmour has the soul of a thousand and does for rock what Mozart did for classical or John Coltrain did for jazz Back2TFuture
- WOW ! Beautiful. An impressive layering of images. Undergroundvibration
- @dannyhughs They would put him next to The Wall full with Animals, and record him playing The Division Bell so that the aliens can make The Final Cut for their dear old Atom Heart Mother. When they put Gilmour back on earth after being planted on The Dark Side of The Moon, there was A Momentary Lapse of Reason between him and the aliens. So he watched as they flew away in their Saucerful of Secrets, and the only other man to see this was The Piper At The Gates of Dawn. darkmachete
- ‚Like“ button?? where is the EPIC button??? ezerlab
- This song makes me want to cry, laugh, sing, hug and get high…all at the same time infidel93
- I’ve never seen this, but it’s one of the better performances i’ve seen from Gilmour and band. Seeing David over the years, and watching the members of Floyd drift into the other side one at a time, wow. His style will never be duplicated, personality on the strings never imitated, the rest never forgotten. Such feeling, such passion, you feel life itself in every note. Not many else on this planet, or any other for that matter, can accomplish that, ever. Firewhiz911
- I need to see David before i die systemofazeppelin666
- I’m only 9 and I love Pink Floyd! countdankula1
- That’s the most fundamental difference between Waters and Gilmour. Waters likes things to be exactly precise every time while Gilmour likes to create sound on the fly with his mind and soul, that’s why there are so many versions of this solo and ALL are amazing. I can’t say I like any version better than others. Each time I listen, I hear a new note or 2 that appeal to me. logiotek
- We don’t need no Jonas Brothers, We don’t need no Bieber Boy, No David Guetta in the classroom, Gaga leave them Kids alone, HEY, GAGA! LEAVE THEM KIDS ALONE! ALL IN ALL, YOU’RE JUST ANOTHER POPSTAR IN THE MALL.TheKkrriissii
- -Easy -Medium –Hard –Expert –Asian –God -David Gilmour Freemanf4
- They say hearing is the last sense to go, before death takes you away. I’d like to hear this song, when i’m dying! No better way to leave than with this relaxing and beautiful music! Korg8000
- Why wasnt i born in the 60’s or 70’s? This is bullshit, now i cant see them live :(( Rampagingnoob
- It will truely be a sad day when Sir David Gilmour passes. It will be the end of something incredible. ToriAnneSmith
- call me crazy but wasn’t gilmore the one who really made the strat live up to it’s name,even more than hendrix did. I mean,a gilmore solo,with his blend of effects would take off into the…….. „stratosphere“? rw5791
- …for a reason I can’t explein he makes me cry…his way to play guitar touch my soul so deeply…ludwig6660
- People spending $3000 on Signature BlackStrat Gilmour guitars..and here this man gets the same feeling with an acoustic. bleedinfretboard
- @bleedinfretboard 4 LUCK IN THIS WORLD THERE ARE THINGS THAT CAN’T BE BUY pablopixies
- I love David Gilmour. He has so much emotion in all of his solos. He tells a story in each one of them. straitoutdabox
- There are no words in the English Language to describe the beauty of this composition !!!! This man brings out emotions which very few musicians, if any, in the world can do !! Long Live DG !! Love from India (Sad that he has never played here, so far)1973krs
- I’m crying. This is the music of Universe pietromagno
- This was my wedding dance song? with my son, Chad, on August 20, 2011. I cried/sobbed as we danced. This song epitomizes all that I feel for him – he is my life, my soul. kitchingcj
- This was the second time I started crying after listening to Floyd. The first time was when I heard Echoes. Then comes Rick’s singing! Oh how could I forget the sax and guitar too?! How soulful does their music get? I am so sad that Rick passed away. It’s now a world without one of the most talented genius‘ ever! R.I.P Richard:( mysoresriram
- this is the story of my life. Thanks for sharing. Great song. ruzqt4me
- Gilmour has one of the most soothing voices I have ever heard! Brad0451
- Gilmoure is just pure joy to watch and hear ,,hope he stays around for a long long time deansusky
- what a wonderful tone of voice Gilmour has ….! keilopalatoskizis
- I once had to learn this sonnet for English class at school. I didn’t like it that much, but Gilmour’s version is wonderful, so wonderful.. cuteHannahHH
- perfect example of not fast but soulfull playing, damn i love how he make that guitar sing texasbob87
- This guy gets more of out a single note on his guitar than anyone in the world. pavkey88
- when you found some talent like gilmour, you have to throw away all the theory of music martinnob86
- It takes me to a place i can’t explain…DaysLikeYears
- Absolute – The existential David Gilmour. If I was able to return to this life as something else after death, I would want to be one of David Gilmour’s guitars, It would be such a joyous honor to be making such music with this human being. I am in awe of this magnificiant musician. This music touches the heights of the? stars and the depths of the soul at the same time. Theres no way out of here, when you come in your in for good! blizznet
- Pretty sure i’ve listened to this about 20 times now. pur3pwn3r09
- Thanks to all, thanks David Gilmour…We love you, continue to make us dream with your superb and perfect music. alien6390
- Pink floyd is godly. I’m happy to be in this world and to hear they music. metabog
- David Gilmour’s guitar is connected to his soul. selzland
- @TheSKCProductions david pours his heart our in his guirar playing this song is so amazing
- i got high. without drugs. TheThethrasher
@acadianfever You will be very happy to have it, the continuity and power of the entire performance cannot be imparted fully with single clips on YT. The DVD set is 4 hours of pure bliss to any PF f
Zu Pink Floyd:
- I’m on LSD and 1:07 I really think I had the best moment of my entire life. This song, that woman’s beautiful voice, makes me cry every time (LSD or not). Just something about this song, fuck it, this whole album makes me feel at home in a way I did only as a child. God bless you Pink Floyd and that amazing black woman who sings for you. You guys have given so much inspiration and life to other musicians. I never really understood music until my dad bought me this album. Thanks Dad. MrLSDandMe
- Something unusual just happened to me : I was sitting here listening to this masterpiece and my dad said that my face was funny… Then he asked me : „Are you high, son ?“. My answer was : „No dad, I was just sitting here listening to some Pink Floyd.“ Then he smiled and said : „Well, then you are !“ akuriau
- I am a 21 year old Floyd fan, they are and have been my favourite band since the ages of 10 when my uncle gave me ‚Echoes: The Best of Pink Floyd‘. See Emily Play got me hooked at that tender age and I haven’t looked back since, I couldn’t put into words how important this band is to me. They have literally been the soundtrack to my life, they have help me through the bad times and taken the good times to a completely new level. It makes me immensely sad that I will never see Floyd live…justme6263
- Thank you for writing such beautiful music, Mr. Gilmour anyroxtar
- PLEASE David……….LIVE FOREVER!! angrypecker
- David Gilmour – What a life ! rolynstone48
- what a song, what an album, what a man! David i want to thank you for all the music you have given not just me, but the world. You are such an inspiration to me. LONG LIVE GILMOUR! Joeaviation1712
- This is not music, this is a work of art for all mankind. angel44442744
- floyd are the only thing in the world that could make me believe there is something around us, which is actually divine. tazmanARfan
- This just made me cry. jph2000
- no words… just AWESOME! PelatiBoys
- i can listen to this 20000 times a day and I don’t get bored eloyimpacto96
- If there’s one secret to Pink Floyd’s music. It’s that the music itself is on a huge scale, epic, grand, classic. While the lyrics are grounded in the very personal, and intimate. No matter how huge the music gets, it can touch us all on some level. Grandios and understated all at once. That’s true art, at its core. ravenslaves
- Todays bands have no creativity, no growth in music experimentation and knowledge. Todays bands are simple chords, simple lyrics, simple musical themes. The greatest bands are from 30, 40 years ago. Its sad what the music industry has done to itself, and it artists chasing the the smash hit, and quick profit. LYoder3
- Beyond Pink Floyd there’s only Classical Music, and beyond that.. Pink Floyd again. cogitoergobooom
- Without doubt the best 24 minutes on you tube!!!!!!!!!!! pghrunr
- That’s still the world’s best guitar solo, and probably always will be. 🙂 Yownanymous
- Every time I watch this song on live 8 video, I get goosbumps and I get this weird feeling inside of me. I can’t explain the feeling, but I wish I always feel that way!!!! fordescortracer
- why do good people get old coldfootWOW
- At 18:29, Nick Mason takes his headphones off to hear this orgasmic solo canyonero1000
- Music isn’t only about singing , it’s about the feeling , it’s about creation , it’s about art , it’s about theatre.Gilmour is counted with few that do really understands the true meaning & feeling of how to sing and play a song ,he can breathe it!! No one can convey the messages of reality like Gilmour does, his music is spiritual and mind opening on this planet. It helps you to forget all z shit that happens and makes you dream of a better world!! Happy Birthday Mr. Gilmour & always shine on! karimfadlallah1
- Gilmour made you listen and Waters made you think